Friday, 22 July 2011

Writing

I'm a bit lost when it comes to seeing a TV series develop and you can see the writers heading for a car crash two or three episodes before it happens. If it's a series you like its puts you in a tricky position, do I keep watching? Will it get worse?

In the case of Battlestar Gallactica you can see the cracks starting to appear about halfway through season 3 after the story arc bridging season two and three comes to a close. At this point the writers begin to throw out filler episodes (episodes which have no bearing on the main plot) and it shows. Firstly characters start behaving oddly. In life we all have ups and down with our friends and family, but it isn't often that our opinions or behaviours change too drastically, nor do our friends and families. Particularly in the case of family, as adults, we don't have any surprises.We know what each other is going to do or say next because we know them so well. Writers often forget this fact when trying to create dramatic tension. In BSG they spent twenty episodes building a relationship between a father and son based on trust and strong morals, morals neither character would dispense with, and then have them fall out when one of them suddenly changes direction on his moral structure, a change brought on by some minor event.

People don't do this in real life. As a consequence the viewer will then "WTF?" his mates by text or some social networking thing, and everyone's scratching their heads, hoping that the bad writing will play out for the best, which it inevitably doesn't. This does not create dramatic tension. Ever.

The real trick in writing is to make sure your characters don't do an about face for no good reason. This is where the importance of archetypes comes in. Take the incredibly successful LOST. Here we have two show runners working on a story which they have mapped out from the start. They work the finer details of the characters and sub plots out as they go, but the hub of the story is there. This gives them a direction. Its clear that the team behind BSG did not have this approach at the start of the series as they were heavily dependent on the pilot episode being successful. Whether, after being commissioned, they then worked out the direction and structure is not known by me, but what is evident is the lack of archetyping and the trust in not messing around with the those archetypes after. LOST never did this. People develop as they as they experience things in life, but they rarely do an about face.

In fact at points during the series it could be said that the weakest character in LOST could have been Jack (The Hero) as his character almost does an about face in series 3 through to 5, but when he gets to the end you realise he has just gone full circle. Other than this the archtype always remain the same. Hurley (Mother, then The King), Sawyer (Rogue), Sayeed (Soldier), Kate (Heroine), Locke (Priest), Jacob (The King) Desmond (Guide). They never change. (unless under the influence of a spell, spell gets removed, they behave just the way they were before.)

Battlestar Gallactica has Adm. Adama (King) Laura Rosilin (Mother) and that's it. Every other character changes their behaviour at any time to suit the "dramatic tension" driven plots and their background can have additional "flashbacks" added to somehow back up the changes in character, so that the audience might be more accepting of them.

Ergo don't let the whims of creating "drama" to put viewing figures higher. Stick to the story. If the story is good with strong archetypes then it will carry. No need to "frak" with things.

No comments:

Post a Comment