Monday, 12 August 2019

Opinions, opinions, opinions...


I haven't written a blog in a long time, but I wanted to share my thoughts on opinions, or rather my opinions.

I have many opinions and I think most people would agree that I am opinionated and even dominating in the way I voice my opinions. But this always comes with a few caveats.

  1. They are not MY opinions. I hold no real opinions on many subjects, I hold the opinions of others. I choose which opinions I follow or communicate not only on the basis of my feelings, but primarily on the source and evidence provided by the person who communicates the opinion in the first place.
  2. My opinions do not really matter. I may well hold different opinions or views in the future. I am constantly evolving my opinions based on the dialectic that I encounter across the policitcal, scientifc and historical spectrum. I use the word evolve advisedly. For example, I used to believe myself to be a liberal because I thought this was the right way to support my fellow man. When I learned what liberalsim really means, based on evidence and reasoned argument, I went away from this position and I will never return to it as it has been proven, without a shadow of doubt, to be an opinion that is more damaging to the goal of supporting my fellow man than I previously realised. The current place that I am at of "democratic socialism" (with a strong under-pinning of marxist economic theory) may move over to something else in the future if I am provided with strong evidence that unequivocally shows that this position is incorrect or hampers the goal in any way. I have, at this time, seen many attempts from people to argue that point, but no-one so far has provided strong evidence or a reasonable argument that refutes it that cannot be countered with stronger evidence from more reputable sources.
  3. I do not take any opinion or view from the mainstream media commentariat without delving into the source of the view. Some I dismiss entirely because of the vehicle used to push that forward is a well known unreliable source that peddles lies and mis-information, spin and smear. Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian, Express, Times, Mirror, Telegraph, BBC, Channel 4, Sky and any TV headline news channel all fall strongly into this category because there are few regulations making sure that British journalism reaches the standards one would expect to be considered “true” or “balanced” reporting. Even left leaning publications like Evolve and The Canary I view with some scepticism as they have equally been caught out regurgitating untruths that come from unreliable sources, despite them seemingly pushing ideas of fairness, equality and justice. RT, The New York Times are two publications that I might take information or opinion from occasionally, but Reuters, Fox, CNN and Washington Post will probably be ignored. If they lie once, or spin, or smear, then I won't come back to them. My information comes either from independent commentators or more likely, books. The standards and regulations involved when one publishes a book tends to be higher and they routinely list their sources and so it is easier to ascertain not only the author's intention with what they are communicating, but where they obtained their information and evidence.
  4. I am biased and there in no such thing as being “un-biased”. There is always an agenda, there is always a point of view. I tend towards sources that I consider reputable or that are in the area that I consider to be of value because of point 2 above. This is cognitive bias and confirmation bias but as I recognise this I often step outside of my bubble to actively challenge it. If that challenge falls short then I return to my bias. If it does not then I re-evaluate my bias. But the most important thing is that I, like everyone who ever lived, am biased.
  5. I am principally a Buddhist and therefore recognise that all my views, feelings and opinions are as temporary and fragile as the squishy brain in my skull.
  6. I am of above average intelligence, but not a genius. Therefore many people, more expert than me know what they are talking about and should be listened to, unless someone more educated or intelligent has come along and refuted their point of view with strong evidence from better and more reliable sources.
  7. I am emotionally passionate and reactionary and my emotions change and my opinions change with them, day to day. If I am unwell or miserable, angry, then my view will be coloured by that and subject to change. I may regret or challenge my own view within my head the very next day and think “what was I going on about, I should apologise.” and usually do. If I do not apologise it means I looked into it and found that I was not wrong or incorrect in holding the view that I did..
  8. Although I strongly believe or state a point of view based on all of the above it doesn't mean that I expect anyone to take on my point of view. However I do expect that for them to refute it effectively they have to listen and actively engage with it rather than dismiss it out of hand without having considered the above points. Often people will approach with a view or bias that, having listened to it, I realise that I (or someone more educated) refuted years ago and are often surprised or annoyed that I won't agree. IE you're racist? Misogynist? Neo-liberal? Fascist? Then off you go. Your point was disproved long ago by people more intelligent than me. I can't reference them because I have a poor memory (as I say average intelligence and not a genius) but that doesn't mean I'm going to give you time to spout nonsense at me.
  9. I honestly do care if you hold a view that isn't as well read as mine, but I'm not going to suggest you should change your point of view, just leave me be and go about your business. Unless you're a fascist and then you go to the Gulag with a big pile of books to read.
  10. Your lack of effort in learning is not my responsibility, it's yours, so don't be surprised if I dismiss you when you demonstrate (even in one short sentence) that; you have not committed to lifelong development of the mind; actively use the sources in point 3; or display a lack of compassion for your fellow humans.
  11. I am not right about anything, but neither are you. We will all die one day and when we do those opinions we hold so strongly disappear. I may react, I may be dominating, but ultimately I know I am as much of an idiot as everyone else and nothing I say matters, really. Even this.

No comments:

Post a Comment